Her first four children each died of asphyxiation during delivery. The 30 year old’s fifth – a baby girl – was born safely at home, and against all odds. However, when the same expectant mother entered Bihar’s district hospital last Friday, to deliver her sixth baby, she was praying for a boy. She entered the hospital carrying the hopes and dreams of the many family members waiting outside for the news and, as I bore witness to, her prayers were answered.
Through CARE International’s influence within the health sector of Bihar (one of India’s most populated states with 110 million citizens) this mother had been encouraged to deliver her sixth baby in hospital, rather than at home. A decision which instantly improved her and her baby’s chance of survival.
I was visiting the hospital with the local CARE team at the time, to learn more about how CARE is helping transform the state’s healthcare system, and improve the quality of the services available.
This blog is to share a few quick highlights of that work, and pay tribute to the front line health workers who are saving lives each day in Bihar, helping families fulfill their dreams…
Bihar is home to millions of people living on or below the poverty line – estimates vary depending on the criteria used (some recent analysis is here) – however, in rural parts, it can be up to 60%.
Since 2010, various Government and international aid investments in Bihar have accelerated change in vital areas of healthcare. This includes furnishing Community Health Centres (which are facilities containing six beds) as well as smaller, local clinics with more up to date equipment, and providing healthcare workers with more structured training. This enables workers to offer up many of the skills they need to be able to have a real influence on lowering the rates of maternal and child mortality.
According to India’s 2013 census data, approximately 42 new births are registered every minute however, in Bihar, maternal and child mortality rates are higher than the average – 208 out of 100,000 and 42 out of 1,000 respectively. To bring this into context, that equates to approximately 2 mothers out of 1,000 dying in child birth every 23 minutes, and 4 child deaths out of 100 born every 2 and half minutes .
As the CARE Chief of Party, Dr Hemant Shah, explained to me from his office in Patna, the state capital, it is by focusing on three complimentary areas of the sector – the systems, the facilities, and the out-reach support – that CARE is working with the Government and with partner organisations to help bring about change in Bihar.
If more citizens, previously cut off from healthcare services, can be reached, and if the quality of healthcare facilities is improved, alongside changes being made ‘vertically’ in how the system itself functions, Dr Hemant is convinced that more positive advancements can be made in Bihar in the years to come.
CARE has already seen positive results over the past 5 years.
When the work started in 2011, a high percentage of premature babies were not surviving at birth. A “low birth weight” in Bihar is classified as weighing under 2kgs. Most of the state of Bihar is home to subsistence, agriculture based communities and, all too often, mothers from these often marginalised rural communities experience premature deliveries at home due to stress. Before CARE’s programme was launched, they simply had very limited support or erratic services on which to rely.
Through a combination of CARE’s engagement at a grass-roots level, as well as through an incentive scheme offered by the Government to encourage mothers to deliver at Community Health Clinics (each receives USD$23 per baby delivered) where CARE has trained front line workers, these statistics have quite rapidly started to change.
In some cases, mortality rates for low birth weight babies during their first 28 days (across the 8 districts in Bihar where the programme is being implemented) has now reduced to between 10-15% where previously in specific areas it had been recorded as high as 55%.
One of the most important frontline workers in CARE’s cadre is the village ASHA (Accredited Social Health Activist), a critical out-reach function that has helped reduce the gap between rural communities and the various healthcare services available to them.
“We instruct those who have no access to hospitals about delivery and child care at home” tells one ASHA we met, “I also tell them about tuberculosis and leprosy and other illnesses. I ask them to come to government hospital either with me or by themselves, because in government hospital they receive free treatment. If the disease is serious, they can get some money for the treatment, too.”
Two other ASHAs who spoke to us, Mamta Devi and Nazma Khatoon, from Rampur and Naraharpur villages, reinforced the importance of the newborn care services they offer in their roles: “We visit every house and advise people to come to hospital for vaccinations,” Mamta explains, “the first dose of BCG, OPV and Hepatitis injections are given within 24 hours of delivery, and then for other vaccines like measles, we spread awareness in the community and ask mothers to visit the healthcare centres,” Nazma continues.
In addition to vaccinations, front line workers also play a key role instructing the families of pregnant women on birth preparedness, sanitation and keeping properly washed and dried clothes for the newborn babies. Nazma stresses how important it is that they also “advise families to have extra money in hand for any emergencies…because of our efforts, fewer newborn deaths are happening. Even physical defects such as polio have reduced.”
For some of the new mothers we visited last week, such as Ruby and her baby Ruksiba (both pictured, above) the out-reach services provided by the programme are a great source of support, information and advice.
Ruksiba weighed only 2kgs at birth, and the family thought she wouldn’t survive.
It was critical for Ruby, especially as a first time mother, to be able to seek basic guidance from CARE’s workers on breastfeeding, nutrition as well as information on vaccinations.
After one month, Ruksiba’s gained 1.2kgs and Ruby’s confidence in her own decisions around feeding and care had significantly increased, “the ASHA has advised me on how to hold my baby, and how to feed it regularly, and the importance of breast-milk” explained Ruby.
This advice is also made available through a twice weekly “Village Health Nutrition and Sanitation Day” event to which CARE gives operational support. These events bring new mothers together to learn about complimentary feeding, to receive vaccinations, and to learn about how to give their babies the healthy start in life they need.
For the frontline workers engaged through CARE’s work, we heard from many of them last week not just about the positive effects on new mothers, but also about some of the things they as workers had been empowered to do, following CARE’s intervention and training. And, ultimately, how this has instilled in them a sense of pride and appreciation for the jobs they are carrying out and their own career paths.
“We have started focusing on sterilizing medical equipment. Earlier it was not a priority for us”, commented Suganthi, one of the programme’s Auxiliary Nurse Midwives based at Jalalpur Community Health Centre in Chapra, “we are now providing proper care to new born babies. We track the low birth weight babies in the community where earlier we were not able to do this or to diagnose complicated cases. Following the training, we have started diagnosing all complications and referring them to higher centres where appropriate”.
A thousand word blog cannot incorporate the myriad of complexities, cultural norms, and underlying causes of poverty which permeate in a country such as India. However, in the face of the many obstacles facing frontline workers and local communities, this work in Bihar highlights some of the significant and positive changes and shifts in norms which are taking place each day.
CARE is playing its role in this complex eco-system, and hopes to remain active in that for years to come – for it surely will take that to bring about the change that women and their families deserve.
A new mother and her baby at Village Health Nutrition and Sanitation Day event
The short video compilation below also falls short of covering every nuance that is of importance in this narrative. However, it might offer more of a feel for the story – of life changing and life preserving interventions – that needs to keep being told.
Last month I visited Tigray, Northern Ethiopia, to interview farmers and livestock traders faced with the drought effects of one of the most devastating El Niños in 50 years, to learn about their coping strategies in the face of extreme weather patterns.
We wanted to find out how these coping strategies were linked to national and international market systems and how, through these systems, it might be possible to bring about a better deal for those in the supply chain typically made more vulnerable by drought: women.
CARE International, the global NGO and my employer for the last decade, has been operating in Ethiopia since 1984, and works alongside other international and national organisations to bring solutions to those whose livelihoods are invested in agriculture, and who by default are affected by regular market “shocks”.
After 70 years of operations around the world, CARE’s focus within any country programme is to bring about positive changes for women and girls. We do this because of the myriad of existing social and economic injustices faced by women and girls, all over the world, many of which have been described on this blog. At CARE, we talk a lot about “empowering” women and girls, and this encompasses many aspects, including improving access to economic resources for women and, crucially, increasing their control over those resources. Read more…
In case anyone needs ideas for New Year’s Resolutions.
Stunning, on every level…
Christmas is coming and there’s no stopping it. Even here in Saigon the Vietnamese have started to embrace what has become an indulgent festival of consumption, celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ.
And, at this time every year, people like me pen blogs like this one, instigated to push a perspective your way. People like me who (you’ll soon enough not be surprised to read) have just spent half my week up in rural Vietnam, meeting local communities.
So, what’s the perspective I’m peddling ? Well, no doubt by the end of this post I will have worked it out… Read more…
I’m back on the regional conference circuit at the moment, and it’s awash with talk about “scale” and “impact”.
Sound-bite central, indeed, with events I’ve attended recently also still obsessing with how to achieve scale and impact by working in “partnerships”. As suggested in my last post we need to look beyond semantics in the sustainability arena, and instead get real about what some of these terms actually mean as, all too often, our preoccupation with the vernacular distracts us from action.
The UN’s new Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have included “global partnerships” as their 17th Goal. The proof of authenticity around what the UN thinks can be achieved with this Goal will be revealed over time. However, right now, it seems to me that if you are not talking about “scaling your programmes”, or “measuring the impact” of your efforts (in terms of playing a positive role in society) then you are not “on message” – and that, for many, is a public relations cardinal sin. Read more…
Over the last couple of months I’ve spent time at various “partnership” themed events. Bangkok, Singapore, Hanoi, even the leafy outskirts of Atlanta, Georgia, many thousands of miles away from the hustle bustle of Saigon. Different venues, but similar take-away recommendations about how, if we are truly to tackle social and environment issues and bring about change in the future, for the future, we must join forces with others.
In some cases, forming alliances which might seem oxymoronic: for example, big business in partnership with local communities; municipal governments working with large NGOs.
Previous case studies on this blog site (where CARE is partnering with companies in the region, including GSK and Diageo) are backed up by hundreds more out there, many of which are breaking new ground and offer hope for replicating models which others can adopt, adapt and improve. Read more…